SB 827: Power play undermines courts and clean air

 
CLCV Opposed
Passed Senate 27-9 (9/12/09)
Passed Assembly 45-21 (9/12/09)
Signed by the Governor

When a court found that the South Coast Air Quality Management District was violating the California Environmental Quality Act by awarding emission credits that were reserved for small businesses and essential public services to new power plants, the district decided to go around the law rather than comply with it. The end product of a very complicated and unsavory legislative process was SB 827 (Wright), which abrogates the court decision that found the air district in violation of CEQA and requires the district to use emission credits that may well result in an increase of air pollution in the nation’s dirtiest air basin.

Issue: 
Air Quality
Senator Party Vote
Sam Aanestad R
Bad
Bad
Elaine Alquist D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Roy Ashburn R
Bad
Bad
John Benoit R
Bad
Bad
Ron Calderon D
Bad
Bad
Gil Cedillo D
Bad
Bad
Dave Cogdill R
Bad
Bad
Ellen Corbett D
Good
Good
Lou Correa D
Bad
Bad
Dave Cox R
Bad
Bad
Jeff Denham R
Bad
Bad
Mark DeSaulnier D
Good
Good
Denise Ducheny D
Bad
Bad
Bob Dutton R
Bad
Bad
Dean Florez D
Bad
Bad
Loni Hancock D
Good
Good
Tom Harman R
Bad
Bad
Dennis Hollingsworth R
Bad
Bad
Bob Huff R
Bad
Bad
Christine Kehoe D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Mark Leno D
Good
Good
Carol Liu D
Good
Good
Alan Lowenthal D
Good
Good
Abel Maldonado R
Bad
Bad
Gloria Negrete McLeod D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Jenny Oropeza D
Bad
Bad
Alex Padilla D
Bad
Bad
Fran Pavley D
Good
Good
Curren Price D
Bad
Bad
Gloria Romero D
Bad
Bad
George Runner R
Bad
Bad
Joe Simitian D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Darrell Steinberg D
Bad
Bad
Tony Strickland R
Bad
Bad
Mimi Walters R
Bad
Bad
Pat Wiggins D
Good
Good
Lois Wolk D
Bad
Bad
Rod Wright D
Bad
Bad
Mark Wyland R
Bad
Bad
Leland Yee D
Good
Good
Assemblymember Party Vote
Anthony Adams R
Bad
Bad
Tom Ammiano D
Good
Good
Joel Anderson R
Bad
Bad
Juan Arambula I
Good
Good
Karen Bass D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Jim Beall D
Good
Good
Bill Berryhill R
Bad
Bad
Tom Berryhill R
Bad
Bad
Sam Blakeslee R
Bad
Bad
Marty Block D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Bob Blumenfield D
Bad
Bad
Steven Bradford D
Bad
Bad
Julia Brownley D
Good
Good
Joan Buchanan D
Good
Good
Anna Caballero D
Good
Good
Charles Calderon D
Bad
Bad
Wilmer Amina Carter D
Bad
Bad
Wesley Chesbro D
Good
Good
Connie Conway R
Bad
Bad
Paul Cook R
Bad
Bad
Joe Coto D
Bad
Bad
Mike Davis D
Bad
Bad
Hector De La Torre D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Kevin de León D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Chuck DeVore R
Bad
Bad
Bill Emmerson R
Bad
Bad
Mike Eng D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Noreen Evans D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Mike Feuer D
Good
Good
Nathan Fletcher R
Bad
Bad
Paul Fong D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Felipe Fuentes D
Bad
Bad
Jean Fuller R
Bad
Bad
Warren Furutani D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Ted Gaines R
Bad
Bad
Cathleen Galgiani D
Bad
Bad
Martin Garrick R
Bad
Bad
Danny Gilmore R
Bad
Bad
Curt Hagman R
Bad
Bad
Isadore Hall D
Bad
Bad
Diane Harkey R
Bad
Bad
Mary Hayashi D
Bad
Bad
Edward P. Hernandez D
Bad
Bad
Jerry Hill D
Good
Good
Alyson Huber D
Good
Good
Jared Huffman D
Good
Good
Kevin Jeffries R
Bad
Bad
Dave Jones D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Steve Knight R
Bad
Bad
Paul Krekorian D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Ted Lieu D
Bad
Bad
Dan Logue R
Bad
Bad
Bonnie Lowenthal D
Good
Good
Fiona Ma D
Good
Good
Tony Mendoza D
Bad
Bad
Jeff Miller R
Bad
Bad
Bill Monning D
Good
Good
Pedro Nava D
Good
Good
Brian Nestande R
Bad
Bad
Roger Niello R
Bad
Bad
Jim Nielsen R
Bad
Bad
John A. Pérez D
Good
Good
V. Manuel Pérez D
Bad
Bad
Anthony Portantino D
Good
Good
Ira Ruskin D
Good
Good
Mary Salas D
Good
Good
Lori Saldaña D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Jim Silva R
Bad
Bad
Nancy Skinner D
Good
Good
Cameron Smyth R
Bad
Bad
Jose Solorio D
Bad
Bad
Audra Strickland R
Bad
Bad
Sandré Swanson D
Bad
Bad
Tom Torlakson D
Bad
Bad
Norma Torres D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Alberto Torrico D
No Vote Good
No Vote Good
Van Tran R
Bad
Bad
Mike Villines R
Bad
Bad
Mariko Yamada D
Good
Good
 
 
 

Take Action »

Be an environmental champion: take action to protect our air, water, and health.

Know Your Legislators »

Who represents you in the Assembly & State Senate? Find out how they voted on key environmental proposals.

Stay Connected »

Keep up with the latest from CLCV: environmental news, urgent action alerts, and more.

Donate »

Your support for CLCV helps maintain California's standing as the nation's environmental leader.

2018 California Environmental Scorecard

New for the 2018 legislative session: The 45th annual California Environmental Scorecard rates elected officials on 2018, another successful year for the environment in spite of heavy opposition from polluting industry.

Find out how your legislators did in 2018 in CLCV's California Environmental Scorecard.